Tim Crook







Useful idiots or Big Brother's antidote? Analysing the ethical role of the state, Guardian and Edward Snowden in the controversy over surveillance and whistle-blowing

This paper takes a critical approach to the Guardian's coverage and the British secret state's position on the revelations by Edward Snowden of global surveillance by the NSA and GCHQ. It contextualises the issues and events with reference to intelligence conflicts from the past. How does the position of the Guardian, its former journalist Glenn Greenwald and the source Edward Snowden compare to the 'useful idiot' syndrome of the 1930s? This was the tendency of some British journalists and public figures to not recognise the true nature of Joseph Stalin's regime in the Soviet Union. The analysis focuses on the trend for state surveillance bodies, whistle-blowers, and their receiving journalists and publishers to each claim the moral high ground of public interest. The tension remains a struggle between those who claim to be protecting national security and those who claim to be protecting individual privacy and seeking to expose alleged abuse of state power through excessive surveillance and electronic intrusion. The opposite sides in this debate appear to delegitimise each other's ethical authority. The paper concludes that in the absence of clear evidence of impact it is difficult to prove which side has been responsible for damaging or indeed improving the public good.

Keywords: Edward Snowden, useful idiots, surveillance, interception, bugging, Guardian


References

  1. Agee, Philip (1975) Inside the Company: CIA diary, London, Penguin
  2. Andregg, Michael (2010) Ethics and professional intelligence, Johnson, Loch K. (ed.) The Oxford handbook of national security intelligence, Oxford, Oxford University Press pp 735-53
  3. Bamford, James (2008) The shadow factory: The ultra-secret NSA from 9/11 to the eavesdropping on America, New York, Doubleday
  4. Bunyan, Tony (1977) The political police in Britain, London, Quartet Books
  5. Crook, Tim (2009) Comparative media law and ethics, London, New York, Routledge
  6. Davies, Nick (2014) Hack attack: How the truth caught up with Rupert Murdoch, London, Chatto & Windus
  7. Ellsberg, Daniel (2002) Secrets: A memoir of Vietnam and the Pentagon Papers, New York, Viking Press
  8. Goodale, James C. (2013) Fighting for the press: The inside story of the Pentagon Papers and other battles, New York, Cuny Journalism Press
  9. Greenwald, Glenn (2015) No place to hide: Edward Snowden, the NSA and the surveillance state, London, Penguin
  10. Harding, Luke (2014) The Snowden files: The inside story of the world's most wanted man, London, Guardian Faber Publishing
  11. Holroyd, Michael (1998) Bernard Shaw: A biography, London, Vintage
  12. Kershaw, Ian (2004) Making friends with Hitler: Lord Londonderry and the roots of appeasement, London, Allen Lane
  13. Klein, Mark (2009) Wiring up the Big Brother machine ... and fighting it, Charleston, South Carolina, BookSurge
  14. Knightley, Phillip (2004) The first casualty: The war correspondent as hero and myth-maker from the Crimea to Iraq, Baltimore Maryland, Johns Hopkins University Press, third edition
  15. Lewis, Paul and Evans Rob (2013) Undercover: The true story of Britain's secret police, London, Guardian/Faber Publishing
  16. Lucas, Edward (2014) The new Cold War: Putin's threat to Russia and the West, London, Bloomsbury
  17. Muggeridge, Malcolm (1981) The infernal grove: Chronicles of wasted time Vol. II, London, Fontana
  18. Petley, Julian (2014) The state journalism is in: Edward Snowden and the British press, Ethical Space: The International Journal of Communication Ethics, Vol. 11, Nos 1/2 pp 9-18
  19. Ponting, Clive (1985) The right to know: The inside story of the Belgrano affair, London & Sydney, Sphere Books Limited
  20. Rayfield, Donald (2005) Stalin and his hangmen: The tyrant and those who killed for him, London, Random House
  21. Snepp, Frank (1999) Irreparable harm: A firsthand account of how one agent took on the CIA in an epic battle over free speech, Lawrence, Kansas, University Press of Kansas
  22. Taylor, Sally J (1990) Stalin's apologist, Walter Duranty: The New York Time's man in Moscow, Oxford, Oxford University Press
  23. Coulson & Anor v. R (2013) EWCA Crim 1026, 28 June. Available online at http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Crim/2013/1026.html, accessed on 10 November 2014
  24. Chapman & Ors, v. R. (2015) EWCA Crim 539, 26 March. Available online at http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Crim/2015/539.html, accessed on 1 May 2015
  25. Miranda, R. (on the application of) v Secretary of State for the Home Department and Anor (2013) EWHC 2609 (Admin) 23 August. Available online at http://www.bailii.org/cgi-bin/markup.cgi?doc=/ew/cases/EWHC/Admin/2013/2609.html
  26. Miranda v Secretary of State for the Home Department & Ors (2014) EWHC 255 (Admin) 19 February. Available online at http://www.bailii.org/cgi-bin/markup.cgi?doc=/ew/cases/EWHC/Admin/2014/255.html
  27. The Litvinenko Inquiry (2015) Available online at https://www.litvinenkoinquiry.org/, accessed on 15 October 2015
  28. The Detainee Inquiry (2010-2013) Available online at http://www.detaineeinquiry.org.uk/, accessed on 15 October 2015
  29. Ackerman, Spencer and Rushe, Dominic (2013) NSA director: Edward Snowden has caused irreversible damage to US, Guardian, 23 June. Available online at http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jun/23/nsa-director-snowden-hong-kong, accessed on 20 April 2015
  30. Aftergood, Steven (2011) In Drake leak case, govt seeks to block unclassified info, FAS, Federation of American Scientists, 12 May. Available online at https://fas.org/blogs/secrecy/2011/05/drake_unclassified/, accessed on 1 November 2015
  31. Apuzzo, Matt (2015) CIA officer is found guilty in leak tied to Times reporter, New York Times, 26 January. Available online at http://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/27/us/politics/cia-officer-in-leak-case-jeffrey-sterling-is-convicted-of-espionage.html, accessed on 1 November 2015
  32. Associated Press (2015) Former CIA man Jeffrey Sterling gets 42 months in prison over Iran leaks, Guardian, 11 May. Available online at http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/may/11/former-cia-man-jeffrey-sterling-42-months-prison-iran-leaks, accessed on 1 November 2015
  33. Bradburn, Howard and Taylor, Peter (2015) Edward Snowden: Spies and the law, Panorama, 5 October. Available online at http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b06h7j3b/panorama-edward-snowden-spies-and-the-law, accessed on 20 October 2015
  34. Burkeman, Oliver and Norton-Taylor, Richard (2004) The spy who wouldn't keep a secret, Guardian, 26 February. Available online at http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2004/feb/26/interviews.iraq, accessed on 1 November 2015
  35. Cole, David (2014) The three leakers and what to do about them, New York Review of Books, 6 February. Available online at http://www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/2014/feb/06/three-leakers-and-what-do-about-them/, accessed on 10 September 2015
  36. Coombs, David and Sweeney, John (2010a) The Documentary, Useful idiots, Episode 1, CTVC Production for BBC World Service, 8 August 2010. Available online at http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p008vd41, accessed on 30 March 2015
  37. Coombs, David and Sweeney, John (2010b) The Documentary, Useful idiots, Episode 2, CTVC Production for BBC World Service, 15 August 2010. Available online at http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p008z6sg, accessed on 30 March 2015
  38. Crook, Tim (2013a) The legal case for protecting April Casburn, Press Gazette, 11 February. Available online at http://www.pressgazette.co.uk/content/legal-case-protecting-april-casburn, accessed 20 August 2015
  39. Crook, Tim (2013b) Alan Rusbridger evokes First Amendment to backward UK, The Conversation, 4 December. Available online at https://theconversation.com/alan-rusbridger-evokes-first-amendment-to-backward-uk-21129, accessed 20 September 2015
  40. Davies, Caroline and Meikle, James (2012) Gareth Williams's death was 'criminally mediated', says coroner, Guardian, 2 May 2012. Available online at http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2012/may/02/gareth-williams-coroner-never-solved, accessed on 10 October 2015
  41. GCHQ (2015) GCHQ funding and controls. Available online at http://www.gchq.gov.uk/how_we_work/running_the_business/Pages/Funding-financial-controls.aspx, accessed on 1 November 2015
  42. Glover, Stephen (2013) Stupendous arrogance: By risking lives, I say again, the Guardian is floundering far out of its depth in realms where no newspaper should venture, Daily Mail, 9 October. Available online at http://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-2451532/STEPHEN-GLOVER-By-risking-lives-The-Guardian-floundering-far-depth.html, accessed on 10 January 2015
  43. Greenslade, Roy (2014) Juries in Sun reporters' trials unworried by payments for information, Guardian, 10 December. Available online at http://www.theguardian.com/media/greenslade/2014/dec/10/juries-in-sun-reporters-trials-unworried-by-payments-for-information, accessed on 4 September 2015
  44. Greenwald, Glenn, MacAskill, Ewen and Poitras, Laura (2013a) Edward Snowden: the whistleblower behind the NSA surveillance revelations, Guardian, 11 June. Available online at http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jun/09/edward-snowden-nsa-whistleblower-surveillance, accessed on 20 August 2014
  45. Hopkins, Nick (2013) UK gathering secret intelligence via covert NSA operation, Guardian, 7 June. Available online at http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2013/jun/07/uk-gathering-secret-intelligence-nsa-prism, accessed on 7 May 2014
  46. Hopkins, Nick and Taylor, Matthew (2013) Alan Rusbridger and the home affairs select committee: The key exchanges, Guardian, 3 December. Available online at http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/dec/03/rusbridger-home-affairs-nsa-key-exchanges, accessed on 13 December 2014
  47. Hopkins, Nick and Borger, Julian (2013) Exclusive: NSA pays 100m in secret funding for GCHQ, Guardian, 1 August. Available online at http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2013/aug/01/nsa-paid-gchq-spying-edward-snowden, accessed on 10 September 2015
  48. Levy, Megan (2007) Scotland Yard man jailed for terror leak, Telegraph, 27 July. Available online at http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1558648/Scotland-Yard-man-jailed-for-terror-leak.html, accessed on 5 September 2015
  49. MacAskill, Ewen, Davies, Nick, Hopkins, Nick, Borger, Julian and Ball, James (2013a) GCHQ intercepted foreign politicians' communications at G20 summits, Guardian, 17 June. Available online at http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2013/jun/16/gchq-intercepted-communications-g20-summits, accessed on 20 May 2014
  50. MacAskill, Ewen, Davies, Nick, Hopkins, Nick, Borger, Julian and Ball, James (2013b) GCHQ taps fibre-optic cables for secret access to world's communications, Guardian, 21 June. Available online at http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2013/jun/21/gchq-cables-secret-world-communications-nsa, accessed on 20 May 2014
  51. Martinson, Jane (2015) Sunday Times drops claim that Miranda met Snowden before UK detention, Guardian, 15 June. Available online at http://www.theguardian.com/media/2015/jun/15/sunday-times-drops-claim-david-miranda-edward-snowden, accessed on 1 November 2015
  52. Narayan, Hari (2015) 'Not only can the state intercept your communication, it does', Hindi, 17 July Available online at http://www.thehindu.com/opinion/interview/an-interview-with-alan-rusbridger-about-edward-snowden/article7430262.ece, accessed on 4 November 2015
  53. Newman, Melanie (2015) Boost for press freedom campaign as European court prioritises Bureau's legal challenge to UK snooping laws, Bureau of Investigative Journalism, 20 January. Available online at https://www.thebureauinvestigates.com/2015/01/20/boost-press-freedom-european-court-bureau-case-snooping-laws/, accessed on 10 March 2015
  54. PA Media Lawyer (2014) QC: Alarm bells should have rung with bugging of Sally Murrer, UK journalists need 'shield law' to stop RIPA abuse, Press Gazette, 12 November. Available online at http://www.pressgazette.co.uk/alarm-bells-should-have-rung-bugging-sally-murrer-uk-journalists-need-shield-law-stop-ripa-abuse, accessed on 20 January 2015
  55. Pasquill, Derek (2008) I had no choice but to leak, New Statesman, 17 January. Available at http://www.newstatesman.com/politics/2008/01/british-muslim-story-case, accessed on 1 November 2015
  56. Penrose, Justin (2013) Spy in the bag Gareth Williams was killed to protect Russian 'mole' in MI6, ex-KGB agent claims, Daily Mirror, 17 November. Available online at http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/former-kgb-agent-boris-karpichkov-2800352, accessed on 3 March 2015
  57. Ponsford, Dominic (2015a) Elveden unravels: After four years and 34 arrested/charged journalists, one conviction stands, Press Gazette, 20 April. Available online at http://www.pressgazette.co.uk/elveden-unravels-after-four-years-and-34-arrestedcharged-journalists-one-conviction-stands, accessed on 25 October 2015
  58. Ponsford, Dominic (2015b) The careless way Plebgate police helped themselves to journalists' call records was a Stasi-style nightmare, Press Gazette, 22 July. Available online at http://www.pressgazette.co.uk/content/careless-way-plebgate-police-helped-themselves-journalists-call-records-was-stasi-style, accessed on 10 August 2015
  59. Ponsford, Dominic (2015c) The betrayal of newspaper sources jailed under Operation Elveden casts a shadow over our industry, Press Gazette, 28 July. Available online at http://www.pressgazette.co.uk/content/betrayal-newspaper-sources-jailed-under-operation-elveden-casts-shadow-over-our-industry, accessed on 1 August 2015
  60. Pulitzer (2014) The 2014 Pulitzer Prize Winners. Public Service. Available online at http://www.pulitzer.org/citation/2014-Public-Service, accessed on 1 November 2015
  61. Robinson, Martin (2013) Police forces pay 25million to informants and nearly half is spent by London's Met, 18 June. Available online at http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2343764/Police-forces-pay-25million-informants-nearly-half-spent-London-s-Met.html#ixzz3qjINdvrV, accessed on 15 September 2015
  62. Ross, Brian (2006) NSA whistleblower alleges illegal spying, ABC News,10 January. Available online at http://abcnews.go.com/WNT/Investigation/story?id=1491889, accessed on 1 November 2015
  63. Rusbridger, Alan (2013) The Snowden leaks and the public, New York Review of Books, 21 November. Available online at http://www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/2013/nov/21/snowden-leaks-and-public/, accessed on 1 November 2015
  64. Schmidt, Michael (2013) Ex-CIA officer sentenced to 30 months in leak, New York Times, 25 January. Available online at http://www.nytimes.com/2013/01/26/us/ex-officer-for-cia-is-sentenced-in-leak-case.html, accessed on 1 November 2015
  65. Shorrock, Tim (2013) Obama's crackdown on whistleblowers, Nation, 26 March. Available online at http://www.thenation.com/article/obamas-crackdown-whistleblowers/, accessed on 1 November 2015
  66. Slack, James (2015) Snowden leaks 'put spies at risk': May says traitor has damaged intelligence agencies across the world including MI5 and MI6, Daily Mail, 18 March. Available online at http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2999878/Snowden-leaks-spies-risk-says-traitor-damaged-intelligence-agencies-world-including-MI5-MI6.html, accessed on 20 August 2015
  67. Telegraph (2013) Glenn Greenwald threatens UK after partner's Heathrow detention, Telegraph, 19 August. Available online at http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/10253544/Glenn-Greenwald-threatens-UK-after-partners-Heathrow-detention.html, accessed on 1 November 2015
  68. Wintour, Patrick (2015) Only 'tiny handful' of ministers knew of mass surveillance, Clegg reveals, Guardian, 5 November. Available online at http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/nov/05/nick-clegg-cabinet-mass-surveillance-british-spying, accessed on 6 November 2016
  69. Young, John and Natsios, Debora (1996-2015) Cryptome, Available online at https://cryptome.org/cryptome-archive.htm, accessed on 1 November 2015

Note on the contributor

Tim Crook is Professor of Media and Communication at Goldsmiths, University of London, and Visiting Professor of Broadcast Journalism at Birmingham City University. He has authored six books on media law, journalism and radio.