Reporting mass random shootings: The copycat effect?
This paper argues that a new understanding of the mass random shooting crime is urgently required. The guidelines for journalists relating to the reporting of suicide have shown the value of understanding the effects of certain types of news coverage on susceptible minds. The mass random shooting crime is excluded from such guidelines because there is no clear evidence for a copycat effect. This paper, however, demonstrates that while the mass random shooting is not generated from the copycat effect, it might nonetheless be impacted by coverage of other such crimes. If that is the case, then there is an argument for a set of reporting guidelines. A fresh examination and interpretation of an old phenomenon, amok, highlights the possible implications of the framing choices made in the news coverage of a mass shooting.
Keywords: mass random shooting, reporting, ethical guidelines, copycat effect
- Abbott, Alison (2001) Into the mind of a killer, Nature, Vol. 410 pp 296-298. Available online at http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v410/n6826/full/410296a0.html
- Cantor, Christopher H. and Baume, Pierre J. M. (1999) Suicide prevention: A public health approach, Secondary suicide prevention: A public health approach, No. 2 pp 45-50
- Cantor, Christopher H., Mullen, P. E. and Alpers, P. A. (2000) Mass homicide: The civil massacre, Secondary mass homicide: The civil massacre, No. 1 pp 55
- Cantor, Christopher H., Sheehan, Peter, Alpers, Philip and Mullen, Paul (1999) Media and mass homicides: Secondary media and mass homicides, No. 4 pp 285-292
- Cantor, Christopher H. and Sheehan, Peter W. (1996) Violence and media reports - a connection with Hungerford?, Secondary violence and media reports - a connection with Hungerford?, 10 January, No. 4 pp 255-266
- Carr, John E. and Tan, Eng Kong. (1976) In search of the true amok: Amok as viewed with the Malay culture, Secondary in search of the true amok: Amok as viewed with the Malay culture, No. 11 pp 1295
- Christians, Clifford, Ferré, John, P. and Fackler, Mark (2012) Ethics for public communication: defining moments in media history, New York, Oxford University Press
- Cullen, Alex (2015). Germanwings raises questions about pilot suicide, Yahoo 7 News, 3 May. Available online at https://au.news.yahoo.com/sunday-night/features/a/27567615/germanwings-raises-questions-about-pilot-suicide/, accessed on 1 June 2015
- Department of Health and Aged Care (1999) Achieving the balance: A resource kit for Australian media professionals for the reporting and portrayal of suicide and mental illnesses, Canberra, ACT, Publications Production Unit (Public Affairs, Parliamentary and Access Branch), Commonwealth Department of Health and Aged Care
- Dietz, Park. E. (1986) Mass, serial and sensational homicides, No. 5 pp 477
- Duwe, Grant (2000) Body-count journalism: The presentation of mass murder in the news media, No. 4 pp 364-399
- Duwe, Grant (2004) The patterns and prevalence of mass murder in twentieth-century America, No. 4 pp 729-761
- Entman, Robert M., Matthes, Jorg and Pellicano, Lynn (2009) Nature, sources and effects of news framing, Wahl-Jorgensen, K. and Hanitzsch, T. (eds) The handbook of journalism studies, New York, Routledge pp 175-190
- Fox, James Alan and Levin, Jack (1998) Multiple homicide: Patterns of serial and mass murder, pp 407-455
- Kon, Y. (1994) Amok, No. 5 pp 685
- McGinty, Emma E., Webster, Daniel W. and Barry, Colleen L. (2013) Effects of news media messages about mass shootings on attitudes toward persons with serious mental illness and public support for Gun control policies, May 2013
- 23 July, No. 5 pp 494-501
- Marlowe, Lara and Scally, Derek (2015) Germanwings crash: Focus on co-pilot's motivation, Irish Times, 27 March. Available online at http://www.irishtimes.com/news/world/europe/germanwings-crash-focus-on-co-pilot-s-motivation-1.2155123, accessed on 1 June 2015
- Mullen, Paul E. (2004) The autogenic (self-generated) massacre, No. 3 pp 311-323
- Neuner, Tanja, Hübner-Liebermann, Bettina, Hajak, Göran and Hausner, Helmut (2009) Media running amok after school shooting in Winnenden, Germany!, 1 December, No. 6 pp 578-579
- Phillips, David P. (1983) The impact of mass media violence on US Homicides, No. 4 pp 560-568
- Pirkis, Jane E. and Blood, R. Warwick (2001) Suicide and the media: A critical review, Canberra, Canberra Publications Production Unit (Public Affairs, Parliamentary and Access Branch), Commonwealth Deparment. of Health and Aged Care
- Pirkis, Jane E., Burgess, Philip M., Francis, Catherine, Blood, R. Warwick and Jolley, Damien J. (2006) Relationship between media reporting of suicide and actual suicide in Australia, January pp 2874-2886
- Pirkis, Jane E. and Machlin, Anna (2013) Differing perspectives on what is important in media reporting of suicide, No. 3 pp 168
- Preti, Antonio (2008) School shooting as a culturally enforced way of expressing suicidal hostile intentions, No. 4 pp 544-550
- Serazio, Michael (2010) Shooting for fame: Spectacular youth, Web 2.0 dystopia, and the celebrity anarchy of Generation Mash-Up, No. 3 pp 416-434
- Turner, T. H. (1988) Running amok, Secondary Running amok, No. 8577 p. 124
Note on the contributor
Glynn Greensmith is a journalism lecturer at Curtin University. He is a broadcaster for ABC Local Radio in Australia, having previously worked as a radio journalist and Local Radio producer at the ABC. This article is based on his in-progress research thesis at Edith Cowan University examining the news coverage (in Tasmania) given to both the Dunblane (Scotland, March 1996) and Port Arthur (Tasmania, April 1996) massacres. Email: Glynn.email@example.com.
Lelia Green is Professor of Communications in the School of Communications and Arts at Edith Cowan University. During the early 1980s she spent some time working in News and Current Affairs at BBC TV and has written in the past on the ethical implications of coverage of the 11 September 2001 attacks on the United States of America. Email: firstname.lastname@example.org.